AP Physics 1 Rotation
Concept Challenges

Ten sense-making tasks on rotational kinematics. Explain your reasoning for every answer. The explanation counts as much as the answer.

showmethephysics.com

Ranking Task

1. Ranking Rim Speeds

Six disks each spin at a constant angular speed $\omega$ about a fixed axle through their centers. The radius $r$ and angular speed of each disk are given. The red dot is a point on the rim of each disk. (Disks are drawn to scale.)

A r = 0.20 m, ω = 6 rad/s B r = 0.40 m, ω = 3 rad/s C r = 0.10 m, ω = 10 rad/s D r = 0.30 m, ω = 2 rad/s E r = 0.60 m, ω = 2 rad/s F r = 0.50 m, ω = 4 rad/s

Rank the disks by the linear (tangential) speed of the red dot, from greatest to least. If any are equal, show the tie. If the ranking cannot be determined, say so.

Greatest 1 ____ 2 ____ 3 ____ 4 ____ 5 ____ 6 ____ Least

Explain your reasoning. Would your ranking change if you ranked by angular speed instead?

Back to top
Conflicting Contentions

2. Two Riders on a Merry-Go-Round

Maya sits close to the center of a merry-go-round and Leo sits at the outer edge. The merry-go-round turns counterclockwise at a constant rate. (Top view.)

Maya Leo ω axle

Four students discuss the two riders:

Ava: "Leo has the larger angular speed, because he travels around a much bigger circle in the same time."

Ben: "They have the same angular speed, but Leo has the larger linear speed."

Cam: "They go around once in the same amount of time, so they have the same linear speed too."

Dee: "If the merry-go-round starts speeding up, Leo will have a bigger angular acceleration than Maya."

Which student(s), if any, do you agree with? Explain what is right or wrong about each statement.

Back to top
What, If Anything, Is Wrong?

3. The Wheel That Reverses

The graph shows the angular velocity of a wheel. Counterclockwise is positive.

123 456 t (s) 620 −2−6 ω (rad/s)

Student explanation: "At $t = 3\ \text{s}$ the wheel stops, so its angular acceleration is zero at that instant. After $3\ \text{s}$ the wheel spins the other way, so its angular acceleration changes from negative to positive."

What, if anything, is wrong with this explanation? If something is wrong, explain the error and give the correct description of the angular acceleration. If nothing is wrong, explain why it is correct.

Back to top
Linked Multiple Choice

4. Speeding Up or Slowing Down?

A wheel rotates about a fixed axle. Counterclockwise is the positive direction.

+ (CCW)

For each case, choose what is happening to the wheel's angular speed at that instant:

A. speeding up    B. slowing down    C. constant angular speed    D. cannot be determined

CaseChoice
(a) $\omega = +4\ \text{rad/s}$, $\alpha = +2\ \text{rad/s}^2$
(b) $\omega = +4\ \text{rad/s}$, $\alpha = -2\ \text{rad/s}^2$
(c) $\omega = -4\ \text{rad/s}$, $\alpha = -2\ \text{rad/s}^2$
(d) $\omega = -4\ \text{rad/s}$, $\alpha = +2\ \text{rad/s}^2$
(e) $\omega = -4\ \text{rad/s}$, $\alpha = 0\ \text{rad/s}^2$
(f) $\alpha = -2\ \text{rad/s}^2$ (no information about $\omega$)

Explain the rule you used. What do the cases with the same answer have in common?

Back to top
Comparison Task

5. Small Wheels, Big Wheels

Two bikes ride side by side at the same constant speed of 6.0 m/s. Bike A has wheels of radius 0.20 m. Bike B has wheels of radius 0.40 m. All wheels roll without slipping.

Bike A R = 0.20 m 6.0 m/s Bike B R = 0.40 m 6.0 m/s

For each quantity, state whether it is greater for A, greater for B, or the same for both. If different, give the ratio.

QuantityAnswer
(a) Speed of the axle (center of the wheel)
(b) Angular speed of the wheel
(c) Number of wheel rotations needed to travel 120 m
(d) Speed of the point of the tire touching the ground, relative to the ground

Explain each answer, and calculate the angular speed of each wheel.

Back to top
Predict & Explain

6. The Turntable Speeds Up

A turntable starts from rest and speeds up with a constant angular acceleration of $1.5\ \text{rad/s}^2$. A sticker is on its edge.

α = 1.5 rad/s² sticker starts from rest at t = 0 s
  1. Predict: During the first 2.0 s, the turntable turns through some angle. During the next 2.0 s (from 2.0 s to 4.0 s), does it turn through the same angle, twice the angle, three times the angle, or four times the angle? Explain your prediction.
  2. Check your prediction by calculating both angles.
  3. A student says, "The angular speed at 4.0 s is twice the angular speed at 2.0 s, so the angle turned must also double." Respond to the student.
Back to top
Working Backwards (Jeopardy)

7. Write the Problem

The equation below describes the rotation of some object:

$$\Delta\theta = (2.0\ \text{rad/s})(4.0\ \text{s}) + \tfrac12\,(3.0\ \text{rad/s}^2)(4.0\ \text{s})^2$$

  1. Describe a physical situation this equation could represent. Say what each number stands for.
  2. Solve for $\Delta\theta$. Then find the object's angular velocity at the end of the 4.0 s.
  3. Suppose the object is a bicycle wheel of radius 0.50 m that rolls without slipping. How far does the bike travel during the 4.0 s?
  4. Sketch the ω–t graph for this motion and shade the area that represents $\Delta\theta$.
Back to top
Changing Representations

8. From ω–t Graph to α–t Graph

The graph shows the angular velocity of a spinning wheel. Counterclockwise is positive.

01234 5678 time (s) 8642 0−2−4 ω (rad/s)
  1. Sketch the graph of angular acceleration vs. time on the blank axes below. Label the values, with units.
  2. At what time does the wheel change its direction of rotation? Is $\alpha$ zero at that time?
  3. Find the wheel's net angular displacement from 0 s to 8 s.
  4. A point on the rim is 0.25 m from the axle. What is its linear speed at $t = 4\ \text{s}$?
1234 5678 t (s) + − α
Back to top
Troubleshooting

9. Find the Mistake: Belt and Pulleys

A belt connects a small pulley (radius 0.10 m) to a large pulley (radius 0.30 m). A motor turns the small pulley at 30 rad/s. The belt does not slip.

small pulley r = 0.10 m ω = 30 rad/s large pulley, r = 0.30 m ω = ? belt

Student solution:

The belt connects the pulleys, so they turn together: $\omega_{large} = \omega_{small} = 30\ \text{rad/s}$.

Speed of the large pulley's rim: $v = r\omega = (0.30\ \text{m})(30\ \text{rad/s}) = 9.0\ \text{m/s}$.

So the belt moves at 9.0 m/s.

Identify the error in the solution. Explain the physics of why it's an error, then find the correct angular speed of the large pulley and the speed of the belt.

Back to top
Meaningful / Meaningless Calculation

10. The Skidding Bowling Ball

A bowler releases a ball of radius 0.10 m so that it slides down the lane at 8.0 m/s without spinning at all. For the first several meters the ball skids. Friction from the lane gradually makes it start to spin, until eventually it rolls without slipping.

v = 8.0 m/s ω = 0 rad/s (just released) R = 0.10 m

Riley writes: "Just after release, the ball's angular speed is $\omega = \dfrac{v}{R} = \dfrac{8.0\ \text{m/s}}{0.10\ \text{m}} = 80\ \text{rad/s}$."

  1. Is Riley's calculation a correct description of the ball just after release? Explain.
  2. Is the number 80 rad/s physically meaningful for this ball in any way? If so, what does it represent?
  3. Once the ball finally rolls without slipping, will its angular speed be more than, less than, or equal to 80 rad/s? (Hint: what is friction doing to the ball's linear speed while it skids?)
Back to top